Bear-off puzzle: same pip count, very different odds
Published · By TG, the site operator
A bear-off puzzle with no contact left. The answer was calculated exactly, trying every roll for both sides.
The position
You are White and have rolled 5-2. Four of your checkers are left: one on your 6-point, two on your 4-point and one on your 3-point. Black has six checkers left, all on Black's 1-point. You have borne off eleven and Black nine, so nobody can be gammoned: the game is worth 1 point on the win chart. The pip counts read White 17, Black 6.
Your options
The 5 cannot bear off from your 4- or 3-point while the 6-point is occupied, because a die bigger than the point may only take a checker from your highest occupied point. That leaves three legal plays, the same three this site's move checker accepts (6/1 means from the 6-point to the 1-point):
- 6/1 4/2: nothing comes off; one checker each on the 4-, 3-, 2- and 1-points. Pip count 10.
- 6/4 4/off: the 2 brings the back checker to the 4-point so the 5 can bear one off. Three checkers left, pip count 11.
- 6/1 3/1: two checkers on the 4-point and two on the 1-point. Pip count 10.
Which play wins most often?
Show the answer
6/1 4/2. With best play by both sides afterwards, White wins 62.9% after 6/1 4/2, 57.8% after 6/4 4/off and 39.8% after 6/1 3/1.
Black takes off at most four checkers a roll, so Black needs two or three more rolls, and two only with a double on one of them (11 chances in 36). Whatever you play, your next roll finishes only with 4-4, 5-5 or 6-6. So what counts is how often you are off within two rolls: 87.0% from the 4-3-2-1 spread, 79.6% after bearing one off, 53.6% from the 4-4-1-1 stack.
From the spread, every roll next turn can take two checkers off. From the stack, half of the 36 rolls leave three or more checkers, because a 2 or 3 cannot bear off from the 1-point while the 4-point is occupied and has to move a checker down instead. Bearing one off now wastes a pip and empties the 1- and 2-points, so after a small roll the last two checkers often sit too high to be sure of coming off.
What it says about pip counts
Two plays leave the same pip count, yet one wins about 23 percentage points more often. After the best play you also trail 10 pips to 6 and are still the favourite, because six checkers take Black three rolls unless a double comes. Late in a game, count checkers and missing rolls, not only pips.
In a 1979 New York Times column, reprinted on bkgm.com, Paul Magriel put taking off as many checkers as possible first, and advised using a number that cannot bear off to fill an empty point so later rolls do not miss. Here the first rule picks 6/4 4/off, but filling the gaps wins about five percentage points more often. The U.S. Backgammon Federation's rules confirm you are never forced to bear off when another legal move exists.
Try it on the table
You cannot load this position here, but such choices come up whenever a game ends in a pure race. Against the computer, check the pip counts and borne-off counts in the panel called The race home, then count the rolls that would miss before you move. Start a game at Easy, Normal or Hard; the guide explains when bearing off is allowed.
Sources
- Backgammon Basics: How To Play — U.S. Backgammon Federation
- Beginner's Instinct at Times May Prevail over Experience (Paul Magriel, New York Times column) — bkgm.com, 2 December 1979
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.