Puzzle: when only one die fits, which one must you play?
Published · By TG, the site operator
Sometimes a roll gives you two numbers, but the position lets you use only one of them. This puzzle is that case, and the rule that settles it is easy to misread when the smaller number looks like the safer move. Every answer below was checked by a script that ports this site's move code and tries every legal sequence.
The position
You are White and have rolled 5-2. The position is made up so that only a few checkers can move. You have one checker on your 13-point, six on your 24-point and eight on your 2-point. Black holds your 6-point with two checkers, your 19-point with two, your 22-point with two and your 23-point with nine.
A point with two or more enemy checkers is closed to you. The 5 from your 13-point lands on your 8-point, which is empty, and the 2 lands on your 11-point, also empty. From your 24-point the 5 lands on the closed 19-point and the 2 on the closed 22-point. Your eight checkers on the 2-point cannot move with either number.
Can you play both dice?
No. After the 5 (13 to 8) the 2 would need to go from 8 to 6, and the 6-point is closed. After the 2 (13 to 11) the 5 would need to go from 11 to 6, which is closed too. Each die has a legal first move, but no sequence plays both.
Which die is forced?
Our guide gives the rule in its second point: if only one of two different dice can be played, you play the higher one when that higher number has a legal landing. The U.S. Backgammon Federation's basics page says the same thing: if either number can be played but not both, the player must play the larger one.
So the 2 is not a choice. The only legal play is 13/8, using the 5. The move 13/11 is refused by the game, even though the 11-point is empty.
Start a game and watch the dice →
When both dice must be used
Change one thing. Suppose Black's 6-point held a single checker, a blot you could hit. Now both dice can be played in either order: 13/11 then 11/6 hitting the blot, or 13/8 then 8/6 hitting it. The rule now asks you to use both numbers, because the federation's page says a player must use both numbers when this is legally possible. The order is your choice.
Show the answer
Play 13/8 with the 5. It is the only legal first move, and after it no 2 can be played, so the turn ends with one checker moved. Trying 13/11 with the 2 is not legal, because a larger die can be played.
In the variant with a blot on your 6-point, the answer changes: both dice must be played, and you may start with either 13/11 or 13/8.
Practise it on the table
The board cannot be set to this position, but the same rule decides many turns in an ordinary game. When two different numbers come up and one of them has no partner, look at the larger number first. Our table accepts only moves the rules allow, so a smaller die is refused whenever the larger one can be played. Start a game at Easy, Normal or Hard, and try to work out which die must be played before you click. The guide lists the rules our table uses.
Sources
- Backgammon Basics: How To Play — U.S. Backgammon Federation
- Why a lone backgammon checker is the risk (site guide) — This site
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.