Puzzle: an opening 6-5 has 14 move orders but only 7 boards
Published · By TG, the site operator
Two different numbers can usually be played in two orders, and it is easy to assume that the order also changes the board. For the opening 6-5 on this table it does not. This puzzle counts the legal orders and then the different boards they leave. Every count below comes from running the site's own move code.
The position
Start from the standard set-up. White has two checkers on the 24-point, five on the 13-point, three on the 8-point and five on the 6-point. Black has five checkers on White's 19-point, which is Black's 6-point, so a 5 cannot move a White checker from 24 to 19. White has rolled 6-5 and must play it.
The rules require a player to use both numbers of a roll when that is legally possible. Here both dice can be played, so every legal play uses both.
The answer
A play here is two moves, one for each die. There are 14 legal ways to play the 6-5 if each order of the two moves is counted separately. Those 14 leave 7 different boards. Each board is listed below by the moves that reach it:
- 8/2 and 8/3. Either order gives the same board.
- 13/2. This comes from 13/7 then 7/2, or from 8/2 with 13/8. The second route refills the 8-point, so the board matches.
- 13/7 and 8/3.
- 13/7 and 13/8.
- 24/18 and 8/3.
- 24/18 and 13/8.
- 24/13, with one checker moved 11 points in two steps.
Play the opening 6-5 yourself and see which board you reach →
What it teaches
In this position the order of the two dice never changes the board. Fourteen orders collapse to seven boards, so a player who chooses a play should compare the boards, not the sequences of moves. The same habit helps when more than one play looks reasonable: name the resulting position first, then ask which one you want.
Two of the seven boards, 24/13 and 13/2, are reached by moving one checker with both dice. The other five move two different checkers. The five Black checkers on 19 are why 24/19 is not on the list at all. Try a 5 from the 24-point on the board to see that block for yourself.
Sources
- Backgammon rules: setup and movement of the checkers — bkgm.com, 13 November 2026
Written by the operator of this site from the sources listed above. Spotted a mistake? Email warmeve.label@gmail.com and it will be corrected.